top of page

NYPD Admits It Hasn't Honored a Single ICE Detainer in a Decade: 'Not One'

3 hours ago
3 min read

By Oreo Express | November 21, 2026

New York City's police department just said the quiet part out loud. Under oath, in front of the City Council, the NYPD admitted it has not handed over a single criminal illegal alien to ICE on a civil immigration detainer in ten years. Not one.

“Not one”

NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Legal Matters Michael Gerber testified Friday, Nov. 20, at a hearing of the City Council's Committee on Immigration. Walking council members through the department's new immigration policies, he said:

“We have not honored a civil immigration detainer in a decade, not one.”

He came back to it later in the hearing so nobody could miss it: “It has been a decade since we honored a ... immigration detainer.” He also told the committee, “We detain no one for immigration enforcement.” Courier New York, which covered the hearing, reported the same admission, and Politico reported this week that the NYPD “has not complied with a civil immigration detainer request in the last decade.”

Video: New York City Council livestream, Committee on Immigration, Nov. 20, 2026. Gerber's remarks begin at about 57:28.

The NYPD's own numbers

The NYPD's own detainer reports back him up, and they are ugly. From July 1, 2025, through June 30, 2026, ICE sent the NYPD 9,645 civil immigration detainers. The number of people held for ICE: 0. The number transferred to ICE: 0. All 9,645 were ignored under city sanctuary law.

That's up from 3,672 detainers the year before, and the NYPD's newest report shows another 899 from July through September 2026, every one of them refused. According to NYPD reports, the last time the department honored any detainer was the year ending Sept. 30, 2016, when it held and transferred just two people.

A detainer is ICE asking a jail or police department to hold someone already in custody, for up to 48 hours, so agents can pick them up safely instead of hunting them down on the street. New York's answer, nearly 10,000 times in a single year, was no.

Democrats want it even looser

The hearing wasn't called to fix this. It was called to make it worse. Committee Chair Elsie Encarnación (D) is pushing Intro 1077-A and Intro 1078-A, which, according to the bill texts, would strip the narrow exception that still lets the city honor a detainer backed by a judge's warrant for someone convicted of a violent or serious crime. Gerber said the NYPD supports the bill. The Mamdani administration's immigrant affairs commissioner, Faiza Ali, said it backs “the spirit of the legislation.”

Meanwhile, council members spent the hearing attacking ICE, not the criminals ICE is trying to remove. Council Member Gale Brewer called federal agents “goons,” and Council Member Carmen De La Rosa branded ICE a rogue agency.

Homan: “We don't”

Border czar Tom Homan has had enough. Asked on Newsmax's “Finnerty” Friday night how he works with Mayor Zohran Mamdani, Homan said, “We don't,” adding that ICE can't even get into Rikers Island and will keep running operations in New York anyway, according to TheAmerican's account of the interview.

Here's the bottom line. Every one of those 9,645 detainers was a person already arrested by the NYPD. Instead of a safe handoff while they were already in custody, New York said no, and then Democrats act shocked when ICE agents show up in neighborhoods. That's not sanctuary. That's a choice, and New Yorkers are paying for it.

Sources

  • NYC Council Committee on Immigration hearing video (Nov. 20, 2026): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kh7V_dygIBc

  • Courier New York, Audrey Kemp: https://courierny.com/news/nypd-and-ice-immigrant-trust/

  • Politico New York Playbook PM (Nov. 19, 2026): https://www.politico.com/newsletters/new-york-playbook-pm/2026/11/19/nypd-updates-patrol-guide-for-the-ice-age-01176612

  • NYPD Civil Immigration Detainers reports: https://home4.nyc.gov/site/nypd/stats/reports-analysis/civil-immigration-detainers.page

  • NYC Politics on Intros 1077-A and 1078-A: https://www.nycpolitics.org/on-my-block/nyc-ice-detainer-bills-1077-a-1078-a-drop-serious-crime-exception-nov-20

  • TheAmerican on Homan's Newsmax interview: https://www.readtheamerican.com/tom-homan-mamdani-we-dont-all-of-them-ice-new-york/

Cover photo: NYPD Deputy Commissioner Michael Gerber testifies, frame from New York City Council livestream, Nov. 20, 2026.

Follow @OreoExpress on X for breaking updates, and watch the livestream on Rumble at rumble.com/user/OreoExpress.

Comments


bottom of page